I saw Silent Hill today, and I'd like to address an open letter to the screenwriters of Europe, Japan, and this very country:
It's true, we have some hideous history over here in the Heartland of America, but we never burned witches, okay? We hanged a good few of them, which is what all the Salem business was about, but that was just the one time and we apologized very shortly afterwards. Even Cotton Mather was sorry, which is no mean feat for the forces of reason.
So, in the future, please refrain from relying on dramatic devices featuring Dark Secrets in the form of burnt witches in the buried past of small American towns. It doesn't point up any deep wrong in American history, any blood crying out from the ground. All it does is nudge the audience and say, fundamentalist Christians are supposed to be holy but you know what they're actually really creepy, which, yes, they are, but any fourteen-year-old in Hot Topic can tell you that. It's not news, and it doesn't exactly impart a frisson. All that Ezekiel 25:17-type business, ministers chanting dolefully about the Faithful and the Blood of the Innocent, is just a big plate of country ham for a scenery-chewing actor, dished up by a screenwriter who probably did his research by rereading The Crucible and visiting godhatesfags.com. It is, in short, no longer scary.
(Silent Hill did have some pretty damn scary moments, though, and none of them were from any attempts at storyline-based horror. They were all from OH SHIT WHAT IS THAT THING which is exactly the appeal of the games to me, and that was quite well translated. It also has the best villain-slaughtering of any movie I have ever seen. I recommend it, by way of fun.)